Of all the possible Harry Potter spin-offs, a TV show about the Marauders, either at Hogwarts or as members of the Order, is probably the one fans ask for the most. But who should play the beloved main cast? Cast your votes!

1. Cast James Potter:
   

   Cast James Potter:

   

   Getty Images

   Answer Image Aaron Taylor-Johnson
   

   

   Answer Image Tom Holland
   

   

   Answer Image Suraj Sharma
   

   

   Answer Image Jordan Fisher
   

   

   Answer Image Gregg Sulkin
   

   

   Image: Via Getty Images Dev Patel
   

   

   Via Getty Images

1. Cast Lily Evans/Potter:
   

   Cast Lily Evans/Potter:

   

   Getty Images

   Answer Image Karen Gillan
   

   

   Answer Image Sophie Turner
   

   

   Answer Image Ellie Bamber
   

   

   Answer Image Zendaya
   

   

   Answer Image Madelaine Petsch
   

   

   Image: Via Getty Images Elle Fanning
   

   

   Via Getty Images

1. Cast Sirius Black:
   

   Cast Sirius Black:

   

   Getty Images

   Answer Image Ben Barnes
   

   

   Answer Image Avan Jogia
   

   

   Answer Image Harry Styles
   

   

   Answer Image Booboo Stewart
   

   

   Answer Image Anthony Ramos
   

   

   Image: Via Getty Images Robert Sheehan
   

   

   Via Getty Images

1. Cast Remus Lupin:
   

   Cast Remus Lupin:

   

   Getty Images

   Answer Image Andrew Garfield
   

   

   Answer Image Nick Robinson
   

   

   Answer Image Luke Newberry
   

   

   Answer Image Asa Butterfield
   

   

   Answer Image Daniel Sharman
   

   

   Image: Via Getty Images Sam Claflin
   

   

   Via Getty Images

1. Cast Peter Pettigrew:
   

   Cast Peter Pettigrew:

   

   Getty Images

   Answer Image Jamie Bell
   

   

   Answer Image Dane DeHaan
   

   

   Answer Image Thomas Brodie-Sangster
   

   

   Answer Image Will Poulter
   

   

   Answer Image Elden Henson
   

   

   Image: Via Getty Images Michael Cera
   

   

   Via Getty Images

1. Cast Severus Snape:
   

   Cast Severus Snape:

   

   Getty Images

   Answer Image Louis Garrel
   

   

   Answer Image Tyler Blackburn
   

   

   Answer Image Isaac Hempstead Wright
   

   

   Answer Image Adam Driver
   

   

   Answer Image Connor Swindells
   

   

   Image: Via Getty Images Charlie Heaton
   

   

   Via Getty Images

1. Cast Regulus Black:
   

   Cast Regulus Black:

   

   Getty Images

   Answer Image Ezra Miller
   

   

   Answer Image Logan Lerman
   

   

   Answer Image Timothée Chalamet
   

   

   Answer Image Tyler Posey
   

   

   Answer Image Finn Wolfhard
   

   

   Image: Via Getty Images Willy Cartier
   

   

   Via Getty Images

Did we miss an absolute perfect casting opportunity? Do you have an idea for Lucius Malfoy’s cameo in Season 2? Let us know below! (I won’t stop until a Marauders TV show airs!)